Category Archives: Attribution

Overestimated global warming over the past 20 years

by Judith Curry

Recent observed global warming is significantly less than that simulated by climate models. This difference might be explained by some combination of errors in external forcing, model response and internal climate variability.

Continue reading

Climate model simulations of the AMO

by Judith Curry

What are the implications of climate model deficiencies in simulating multi-decadal natural internal variability  for IPCC’s climate change detection and attribution arguments?

Continue reading

UK Met Office on the pause

by Judith Curry

The recent pause in global surface temperature rise does not, in itself, materially alter the risks  of substantial warming of the Earth by the end of this century. – UK Met Office

Continue reading

Unforced variability and the global warming slow down

by Patrick Brown

How we interpret the current slow-down in the rate of global warming depends very much on the length of the ‘leash’ in the true climate system (i.e., how large internal variability is).

Continue reading

CFC climate bomb (?)

by Judith Curry

Talk about perverse incentives! It appears that Chinese coolant manufacturers have been producing an excess of a harmful greenhouse chemical in order to dispose of it responsibly under the UN’s Clean Development Mechanism (CDM). – Walter Mead

Continue reading

The New Republic on the ‘pause’

by Judith Curry

In the end, the so-called scientific consensus on global warming doesn’t look like much like consensus when scientists are struggling to explain the intricacies of the earth’s climate system, or uttering the word “uncertainty” with striking regularity. – Nate Cohn

Continue reading

Ocean heat content discussion thread

by Judith Curry

So, exactly how are the oceans sequestering heat below 700 m?  And how might this heat return to the surface to impact the surface climate?

Continue reading

More on the ‘pause’

by Judith Curry

Is global warming slowing down? – David Appell

Continue reading

New perspectives on climate sensitivity

by Judith Curry

Here is a summary of some important new papers on the topics of climate sensitivity and attribution.

Continue reading

Macroweather, not climate, is what you expect

by Shaun Lovejoy

When the International Meteorological Organization defined the first climate normal from 1900 to 1930, the belief was that the climate was constant, and that the newly defined climate ‘normal’ would give a close approximation to the climate.

Continue reading

20th century mean global sea level rise

by Judith Curry

On the acceleration of sea level rise, the Gilligan effect, and the garbage solution.

Continue reading

Multidecadal climate to within a millikelvin

by Vaughan Pratt

The title of this post is taken from my AGU Fall Meeting poster presentation on the afternoon of Tuesday Dec. 4 (tomorrow).

Continue reading

Systemic thinking on causation

by Judith Curry

George Lakoff has just thrown  a big can of worms into the global warming debate:

Yes, global warming systemically caused Hurricane Sandy — and the Midwest droughts and the fires in Colorado and Texas, as well as other extreme weather disasters around the world. Let’s say it out loud, it was causation, systemic causation. 

Continue reading

Sunday Mail . . . again

by Judith Curry

The MSM and blogosphere are still roiling over David Rose’s article last Sunday, here is the latest, including a new article by David Rose.

Continue reading

‘Pause’ : Waving the Italian Flag

by Judith Curry

The recent articles in the Daily Mail and the Guardian are generating heated reactions – more heat than light.  Lets break down the arguments on both side and assess them systematically.

Continue reading

‘Pause’ discussion thread: Part II

by Judith Curry

The Guardian strikes back against David Rose’s Daily Mail article.

Continue reading

‘Pause’ discussion thread

by Judith Curry

The latest data release from HadCRUT4 is creating quite a stir.

Continue reading

Workshop on attribution of extreme events

by Judith Curry

Better models are needed before exceptional events can be reliably linked to global warming. – Nature

Continue reading

Apportioning natural and forced components in the Arctic amplification

by Judith Curry

These results support the notion that the enhanced wintertime warming over high northern latitudes from 1965 to 2000 was mainly a reflection of unforced variability of the coupled climate system. Some of the simulations exhibit an enhancement of the warming along the Arctic coast, suggestive of exaggerated feedbacks. – Wallace et al.

Continue reading

Fuzzy dice

by Judith Curry

Much is being made of Hansen’s ‘loaded dice’ as a metaphor for the changing climate.  I think we should be talking about ‘fuzzy dice.’

Continue reading

John Christy’s EPW testimony

by Judith Curry

John Christy’s testimony to the Senate Committee Environment & Public Works Committee can be found here [christy testimony 2012].

Continue reading

Observation-based (?) attribution

by Judith Curry

Moreover, it appears likely that essentially all of this increase results from the human emission of greenhouse gases. These findings are stronger than those of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the United Nations group that defines the scientific and diplomatic consensus on global warming. In its 2007 report, the I.P.C.C. concluded only that most of the warming of the prior 50 years could be attributed to humans.  –  Richard Muller, NYT op-ed

Continue reading

Loaded (?) dice

by Judith Curry

“Climate dice”, describing the chance of unusually warm or cool seasons relative to climatology, have become progressively “loaded” in the past 30 years, coincident with rapid global warming.  We conclude that extreme heat waves, such as that in Texas and Oklahoma in 2011 and Moscow in 2010, were “caused” by global warming, because their likelihood was negligible prior to the recent rapid global warming. – Hansen, Sato, Ruedy

Continue reading

What climate sensitivity says about the IPCC assessment process

by Rud Istvan

If climate sensitivity is high, then modest GHG increases cause significant warming. If it is low, then significant GHG increases will not. Analysis of the IPCC assessment of sensitivity provides another window into the ‘government-climate research’ complex and its propensity to overstate future warming, misrepresent findings, and dismiss challenging evidence.

Continue reading

Explaining (?) extreme events of 2011 from a climate perspective

by Judith Curry

The latest issue of the Bulletin of American Meteorological Society has published a collection of papers that illustrate different methodologies for attributing causes of recent extreme weather events.

Attribution of extreme events shortly after their occurrence stretches the current state-of-theart of climate change assessment. To help foster the growth of this science, this article illustrates some approaches to answering questions about the role of human factors, and the relative role of different natural factors, for six specific extreme weather or climate events of 2011. – TC Petersen, PA Stott, S. Herring

Continue reading